Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Andy Judson's avatar

I remember several years ago reading a paper laying out the issues with scaling up lab-grown meat. Unfortunately, I can't find it, but IIRC the main crux of the article was that it was actually incredibly hard to scale up because you need to maintain a very large and complex space in a completely sanitary manner, as a tiny amount of bacteria getting in could completely ruin a batch of product, and require a large deep-clean. Though 'incredibly hard' was definitely not the same as 'impossible'. Plus, as has been pointed out, there's not really much more you could do to make real meat cheaper, whereas this sounds like a problem that can be worked on, but means that scaling up will take longer than people think.

I ultimately think that the cost of plant-based substitutes will always be cheaper, but that in a lot of cases this will suffice. Certainly in something like a Big Mac, I think a plant substitute would probably get to 'close enough' to be a viable, and cheaper, alternative to real meat. Lab grown meat would probably become a higher end product, where the higher cost can be built in to the price.

Expand full comment
Pete's avatar

Another presumed side-benefit to lab-grown meat, not mentioned in your article, would be not having to administer so many antibiotics. Given that the meat is cultivated in a controlled environment and the "catalyst" would presumably be disease-free, this would be another huge bonus.

I have had a passing interest in lab-grown meat for years now, and it just seems like a dangling carrot to me. I'm sure it'll happen eventually, but so far it's been "just around the corner" for what seems like a very long time.

I think, as others have pointed out, there's still a great deal of vested interest in the meat industry and that's going to be difficult to overcome. My hope is that it will be like EVs (and probably most other "good" things) where it's all a bit niche to begin with, but then word-of-mouth spreads, people get a taste of it and like it, and demand grows exponentially. But this is where your argument comes in. We're not going to have a "Tesla of lab-grown meat" in the UK if there are too many hoops to jump through to get to market.

Anyway, I would switch to lab-grown meat tomorrow if it were widely available. There's no squeamishness here - bring it on!

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts