Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Susan Hofstader's avatar

My suggestion, and I don’t know if it will work but I think might be more persuasive than just saying it’s “bollocks,” is to point out how very Boomer-ish it is to be into Astrology. Hippies were so into that stuff (check out the song “Age of Aquarius” from the musical “Hair”--also an excellent example of astrologers being very, very wrong). On the other hand, that just probably shows that some nonsense is evergreen and young people are always going to be attracted to something that presents as a magical way to find a mate, because goodness knows rationality doesn’t really have much salience in that realm (unless you’re a fan of arranged marriage).

Expand full comment
Charlie Ullman's avatar

I think your 'let's all be the buzz-killing arsehole in the room' strategy might need some more thought. I'm not sure it'll help. I think you anticipate this objection towards the end of your article. But there are a number of assumptions I'd want to be a lot more sure of. Is astrology really on the rise? I tried a bit of aimless Google trends searches and didn't really find a trend. Will calling people out for bullshit change their minds? Or make them believe even more strongly? I think the evidence on this is at best mixed.

There might be a strategy to move society more Enlightenment-wards, but it's not obvious to me what it is...

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts