Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dave Ward's avatar

On the internal Labour stuff, it's not exact but generally there's a big overlap with 'trans rights' and Corbyn supporters. After the Corbyn leadership, and all the arguments over that, and anti-semitism, the party has been in no mood for another big fight. Especially on this issue. So a lot of people have tried to avoid or downplay the issue. As you say, I don't think that can hold until the election. The tories, and campaigners on both sides in the party are now pushing the issue to the fore. We have to deal with it in some way and I don't think there is a fudge which pleases both sides.

Expand full comment
Supdragon's avatar

This is spot on and before I left the Lib Dems, I explained over and over that their ‘no debate’ stance on self-ID meant that a reasoned respectful debate could not be had, which would push this issue into the pages of the Daily Mail, play into the hands of the Tories looking for a post-Brexit anti-‘elite’ lever to pull at election time and give this topic a life of its own.

The saddest part is, people with severe gender dysphoria, the sort for whom surgical and social transition is the only option, are increasingly harmed by the tactics of the trans activists who proclaim themselves allies (and usually ‘cis’ or ‘queer’). Self-ID is not necessary. It isn’t possible to change sex, and there is already a route to change legal gender for paperwork purposes, which includes a sensible degree of safeguarding. If it ain’t broke...

Expand full comment
29 more comments...

No posts