Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ocset's avatar

Out of curiosty as you mentioned being new to trek. I've noticed a big desire amongst modern trek fans to have older trek be ''brought into the future'' with retconning/prequel/reboots and such and was just wondering, would it do the franhcise more good to take all those new ideas and channel them into newer shows with new characters and elements that can explore those, rather than tying them to the chains of very restrictive setting elements. Part of me sees the constant going back and ''recontextualizing'' for ''modern'' audiences a dilution rather than addition, that in the end rarely serves the old or the new.

I understand wanting to use 60's trek to explore as you mention women and their roles in the franchise but I think what has been overlooked by writers of modern trek is that you dont need to go directly back to when trek did something wrong to highlight it, you can easily create context in a newer story that addresses it.

Not a criticism of your opinion, just a curiosty on your desires from the story telling of trek. As a long time fan of trek, I'd love to see early Bajor and the Cardassians explored, I just don't see the value of it being done by characters in TOS uniforms.

To me, the setting has so much space to explore any idea, and I find the obsession the franchise has had with prequels for the past 18 years very restrictive.

These shows were new once, with new characters, settings and stories to fall in love with. As an old fan, it be nice to see newer fans also get that.

Thank you.

Expand full comment
Charles Arthur's avatar

“Perhaps an episode about a rogue AI”

Ah. Tell me you haven’t watched all the episodes of TOS without.. etc. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ultimate_Computer)

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts